Design Issues With Tendons
A composite tendon is essentially a rope made from small-diameter rods, which are pultruded with carbon fiber. Multiple rods are gathered together and twisted slightly to form a strand, using typical wire rope stranding methods. Depending on the performance requirements, 10 to 40 strands, about 2 to 3 inches/5
#outofautoclave #precursor #polyacrylonitrile
A composite tendon is essentially a rope made from small-diameter rods, which are pultruded with carbon fiber. Multiple rods are gathered together and twisted slightly to form a strand, using typical wire rope stranding methods. Depending on the performance requirements, 10 to 40 strands, about 2 to 3 inches/50 to 75 mm in diameter, are bundled together to form a single tendon. The tendon is jacketed with a thermoplastic material for in-service protection, then spooled onto a reel for transport. Composite tendons can be pultruded and cabled in continuous lengths, eliminating the need for intermediate joints, although in deeper waters, it may still be necessary to join multiple sections.
According to Mamdouh Salama, a senior research fellow at Conoco Inc. (Ponca City, Okla., U.S.A.), the high stiffness-to-weight ratio for carbon fiber composites is the key to their utility.
“The tether design is stiffness-driven, so a tendon with the required stiffness actually provides more tensile strength than we need — a benefit that reduces potential fatigue problems in the tether,” says Salama. “In addition, composites permit greater design flexibility for tailoring properties to meet the platform’s specific design requirements.”
Conoco and Kværner Oilfield Products ( KOP, Oslo, Norway) tested different types of carbon fiber composite tendons. Pultruded rods made with 48K, 50K and 80K intermediate-modulus polyacrylonitrile (PAN) carbon fiber and a customized epoxy resin were compared to rods made from a high-modulus 12K pitch carbon fiber in a vinyl ester matrix. The different types of rods performed comparably during tests for transverse strength, torsion and fatigue, although the high-modulus rods showed a greater elastic modulus in static tensile tests (50 percent greater than the intermediate-modulus rods).
The results indicated that large-tow carbon fiber, such as that supplied by Tenax Fibers (Wuppertal, Germany) or Zoltek Corp. (St. Louis, Mo., U.S.A.) is more than adequate to meet the performance objectives. The stiffer pitch carbon fiber produces a thinner tether that weighs less and produces less drag, but at a higher cost. Salama reports that Conoco is working on a reduced-cost high-modulus carbon fiber alternative, but doesn’t expect it to be available for several years.
The results of the Conoco/Kværner test make sense, says Zsolt Rumy of Zoltek. “The modulus or stiffness of commercial heavy-tow fibers is competitive with aerospace-grade fibers for these kinds of projects,” he explains. While heavy tow delivers somewhat less strength, what it lacks is not necessary for the application. Therefore, Rumy concludes, “They perform as well and the cost over the long run will be much less.”
Because composite tendons are inherently corrosion resistant and have few joints that require inspection, maintenance goes down and reliability goes up. In addition, optical fibers can be embedded in the carbon fiber rods to monitor tendon strain during testing and actual operation. Rod or strand failure can be detected electronically by local or remote operators, and receive immediate attention. Optical sensor technology has been successfully demonstrated in performance testing on composite tethers, and is significantly less expensive than the complex and often unreliable conventional steel tether load cells.
CSO Aker Maritime (Houston, Texas, U.S.A.) considered a tubular design for composite tethers. This type of tendon would be neutrally buoyant, reducing required pretension and hull size. However, tubular tendons are not spoolable. Therefore, they must be manufactured and transported in shorter segments and joined at installation. The additional terminations required would add cost, increase maintenance and potentially increase reliability problems. A hybrid tendon concept, consisting of a lower rope segment and upper tubular segment, was not cost- or performance-competitive. A ropelike composite tendon is the currently preferred design.
Lightweight, hard and stable at high temperatures, CMCs are emerging from two decades of study and development into commercial applications.
Fiber-reinforced plastic (FRP) replacing coated steel in more reinforced-concrete applications.
Commercial production of recycled carbon fiber currently outpaces applications for it, but materials characterization and new technology demonstrations promise to close the gap.