General Plastics Mfg. Co.
4910 Burlington Way
Tacoma , WA 98409 US
No Bones About It: Polyurethane Foam is a Better Medium for Orthopedic Models
Traditional Media and Their Drawbacks
Common materials for orthopedic testing and education – most often, cadaver specimens, but also animal bones and wood – while utilitarian, are far from ideal for today's researchers and students. Their deficits are manifold, just a few of which include scarcity, cost, and consistency across specimens.
When it comes to supply and demand, cadavers become available either by donation or via bodies unclaimed after death. The supply funnel is scarce and therefore increases the cost per specimen. Costs also increase due to the associated regulations for storing, shipping, and disposing of human specimens. And ultimately, not all specimens are created equal.
Whether due to individual differences or changes attributable to embalming methods, variations exist across specimens. When combined with the fact that most cadaver bones come from the elderly and infirm, which is not necessarily representative of the population at large, it negatively impacts the consistency needed for medical accuracy and statistical robustness (Horn, 2010; Elfar, 2014).
A Suitable Substitute
The search for a more reliable medium has led many medical researchers and educators to polyurethane foam as the composite material of choice for orthopedic models. Polyurethane immediately addresses the drawbacks of traditional materials in that:
- There is no shortage of supply. Polyurethane foam is readily available from commercial sellers to meet various needs of researchers and educators alike
- Batches can be produced at a substantially lower cost when compared to procuring cadaver specimens
- Depending on selected manufacturer’s methods, consistency across materials batch to batch may be ensured
In addition, polyurethane foam is not subject to the onerous regulations of cadaver bones, and it is resistant to moisture and mold. This makes shipping, storage and disposal simple and inexpensive (Elfar, 2014).
Yet the most important question is whether the polyurethane foam is a suitable analogue for bone? Does it mimic the properties of bone necessary for accurate biomechanical testing? The short answer is yes.
Numerous studies have found polyurethane foam to be a suitable substitute for human cancellous bone both in terms of its mechanical properties and as a substrate for implant testing (Shim, 2012; Horn). Polyurethane can be processed to mimic both the compressive strength and elastic modulus of bone. It can mimic healthy bone, and by adjusting foam density, conditions such as osteoporotic bone can also be recreated for study (Patel, 2008). Rigid polyurethane foam is approved by the American Society of Testing Methods (ASTM) as a standard material for testing orthopedic devices and instruments (ASTM, 2012).
An Experienced Partner
If you are ready to make the jump from traditional materials to polyurethane foam for your orthopedic testing and education, consider General Plastics as your supplier and partner. With 75 years as an innovator in the plastics industry, General Plastics have finely honed quality assurance processes in place and a long track record of delivering on the most stringent customer requirements.
The LAST-A-FOAM® FR-3700 polyurethane foam series is regularly used in orthopedics as artificial media for bone testing. It comes in a range of densities from 3-40 pounds per cubic foot, and thus can be made to mimic human bone across a range of conditions and testing needs. Vitally, they have a consistent cellular structure that closely approximates human bone, so are ideal for research purposes and for medical students to develop their surgical skills.
One recent study (Iweju, 2014) found General Plastic's Last-a-Foam® series to be superior to other polymer materials and grades of polyurethane foam for artificial joint testing. Across a number of qualities important in orthopedic research including density, compressive strength, and tensile strength, General Plastics' Last-a-Foam® products (PU2 & PU3 in the charts below) were the closest analogue to human cancellous bone.
A Message from General Plastics Mfg. Co.
As Seen In CompositesWorld
CAMX 2020 exhibit preview: General Plastics
General Plastics Manufacturing Co. is showcasing its LAST-A-FOAM core products, custom molding capabilities and high-temperature, low-CTE tooling board.
Composites suppliers, fabricators respond to coronavirus
Companies across the composites industry supply chain share how the COVID-19 pandemic is affecting their businesses, and how they are available to help.
CAMX 2019 exhibit preview: General Plastics
General Plastics Manufacturing Co. is showcasing its new LAST-A-FOAM FR-4800 tooling board at its CAMX 2019 booth.
CAMX 2018 preview: General Plastics
General Plastics (Tacoma, WA, US) is featuring its new high-temperature, low-CTE LAST-A-FOAM FR-4800 tooling board.
General Plastics launches ultrahigh-temperature tooling board
General Plastics Mfg. Co. (Tacoma, WA, US) expanded its line of high-temperature tooling board materials with the introduction of LAST-A-FOAM FR-4800, an autoclave-capable, high-density epoxy-urethane foam designed for master plug manufacturing, tool proofing, vacuum form tooling, pattern making, and short-run production tooling applications.
CAMX 2017 preview: General Plastics
General Plastics Mfg. Co. (Tacoma, WA, US) is showcasing its new LAST-A-FOAM RF-2200, a lightweight material that provides an RF-transparent protective layer for radome and antenna applications.
JEC World 2017 exhibit preview
JEC World will be held March 14-16 in Paris. CW previews some of the products and technologies that will be at the show.
JEC World 2016, the full report
CompositesWorld's editors report on the technologies and products that caught our eye at JEC World 2016, in early March.
Composites 101: Tooling
Composite parts are formed in molds, also known as tools. Tools can be made from virtually any material. The material type, shape and complexity depend upon the part and length of production run. Here's a short summary of the issues involved in electing and making tools.
CFRP camera boom enables safe spill inspection
NONA Composites’ 32m REACH structure meets tight remediation schedule at DoE radioactive waste storage site.
Composite tooling without oven or autoclave
No Oven No Autoclave technology has been demonstrated in tooling for NASA, including multiple thermal cycles and use for curing epoxy infused out-of-autoclave parts.
Pierce County trains skilled workers through collaborative curriculum building
Bruce Kendall, the president and CEO of the private, nonprofit Economic Development Board (EDB) for Tacoma-Pierce County (Wash.), reports on the success of a collaborative training curriculum development program that produces skilled workersfor the aerospace industry.
Tooling boards improve processes
In the composites industry, many parts are the product of one-off or few-of-a-kind production programs. In response, tooling material suppliers today provide an increasing variety of relatively inexpensive materials grouped under the heading of tooling board.
SAMPE 2009 Product Showcase
Showgoers at the SAMPE 2009 Conference and Exhibiton in Baltimore, Md. found many suppliers undeterred by poor economic news.
Taking Up Tooling Boards
Tooling Board ManufacturersEpoxy and polyurethane tooling boards are a standby for creating models or low-run-production tooling.
SAMPE 2005 Product Showcase
SAMPE's U.S. Symposium and Exhibition highlights technological innovation and market expansion.
Blast protection for large structures
Hardening of public buildings against terrorist threats represents a potentially huge market for antiballistic composites.
Getting To The Core Of Composite Laminates
A wealth of low-cost core solutions are available for high-performance sandwich structures.