Kraussmaffei Metering Systems
Published

Our "liability" is our greatest asset

HIgh-Performance Composites' editor-in-chief Jeff Sloan questions the wisdom of wishing away, for sake of comfort and ease, the complexity of composites when that very attribute is the key to its effectiveness as an alternative to metals.

Share

I am attending our (CompositesWorld’s) annual Composites Investment Forum this week — as I write — in Fort Worth, Texas. CIF presentations emphasize venture capitalization, mergers-and-acquisitions activity, corporate growth strategies and overall composites industry competitiveness.

A recurring theme at today’s session (Oct. 17), and one heard at many other composites conferences, is the competitive disadvantage composites suffer when positioned against legacy materials, such as steel and aluminum. It’s not that composites can’t compete mechanically or physically, but that with more than 100 years of history, metals are a known commodity — their properties and behaviors are widely known, they are relatively easy to design for and their manufacturing processes are highly developed. Metals are well-entrenched and well-understood. Familiarity breeds content.

Composites, on the other hand, despite their decades on the job, are young by comparison and, therefore, not as well known among design and manufacturing engineers. And as noted at the conference, the composites industry remains almost hopelessly disparate, a tangled soup of resin, fiber, tooling and processing combinations that have assiduously avoided standardization for years. This tendency toward great variety makes it difficult for designers and manufacturers to focus on a few resin or fiber types that provide an easy way to comprehend and meet mechanical requirements.

Here at the conference, the argument is that until composites evolve to standardized material and process types that minimize their complexity, becoming more science and less art with a simplified supply chain, they will remain on the manufacturing fringe, chasing the easy-to-use legacy materials. This is, without doubt, a possible outcome, and a plurality of composites professionals will nod sagely whenever this sentiment is expressed at conferences like ours.

However ....

Before we hurry out to wrest order and simplicity from the chaos that is the composites industry, I have a very basic question: Isn’t the variety offered by composites actually the material’s greatest asset? Composites, by virtue of their adaptability, bring to almost every application a material solution that promises to save weight, increase toughness and prevent corrosion and fatigue problems that plague metals, thus prolonging product life. Just by changing fiber direction, or fiber type and direction, or the fiber/core/resin combination, a patient, skilled designer can precisely dial in strength, toughness, durability and weight performance that can dramatically eclipse that of competing metals. Isn’t this ability to mix-and-match to meet mechanical requirements basic to composites’ DNA?

The implication, thus far, is that the composites industry, to mature, must adapt itself to meet the expectations of the manufacturing and OEM community. And this might be true. But it might also be true that the manufacturing and OEM community, if it really believes in the game-changing potential of composites, has its own adapting to do. It might be true that designers who know and love stainless steel and aluminum should go back to school and bone up on carbon fiber and epoxy and ply orientation. It might be true that engineers have to stop thinking of carbon fiber laminate as a drop-in replacement for metals and rethink completely how best composites should be used in an application.

It’s tremendously appealing to look at the arc of history traced by metals and conclude that composites’ “success” lies along the same path. Perhaps, but I think we should be very careful what we wish for.
 

cut by an Eastman
KraussMaffei Metering Systems
Carbon Fiber 2024
Thermwood Corp.
CompositesWorld
CAMX 2024
Airtech
A manufacturing puzzle
CompositesWorld
industrial CNC routers
HEATCON Composite Systems
Chem Trend

Related Content

Editorial

As 2023 begins, a look back at trending CW topics in 2022

With 2022 now behind us, CW’s editor-in-chief Jeff Sloan takes a look at the CW stories last year that received the most reader attention.

Read More
Editorial

The return of trade show season

SAMPE Seattle, JEC World and the Paris Air Show are approaching fast, and they signal the real emergence of a post-pandemic world.

Read More
Editorial

Welcome to the Composites Age

The human race has a long history of developing materials, each one a little better than the one before it. Composites are among the latest in a long line, and proving highly adaptable to new opportunities.

Read More
Hydrogen Storage

Rational exuberance for emerging markets

Advanced air mobility and hydrogen storage represent a huge opportunity for the composites industry. They will also be hugely challenging.

Read More

Read Next

Filament Winding

From the CW Archives: The tale of the thermoplastic cryotank

In 2006, guest columnist Bob Hartunian related the story of his efforts two decades prior, while at McDonnell Douglas, to develop a thermoplastic composite crytank for hydrogen storage. He learned a lot of lessons.

Read More
Pressure Vessels

Composites end markets: Energy (2024)

Composites are used widely in oil/gas, wind and other renewable energy applications. Despite market challenges, growth potential and innovation for composites continue.

Read More
Trends

CW’s 2024 Top Shops survey offers new approach to benchmarking

Respondents that complete the survey by April 30, 2024, have the chance to be recognized as an honoree.

Read More
CompositesWorld