Making better composite bikes in Arkansas
It’s a fact that the vast majority of bicycles sold in the US are made abroad. According to one source (www.statista.com, data from 2015), 99% of bicycles sold in the US were imported from China and Taiwan. So it was interesting to hear of bicycle manufacturer HIA Velo (Little Rock, AR, US), maker of carbon fiber bikes in the US, in-house, using a combination of composite materials to make their products more durable (the HIA in the company’s name denotes “Handmade in America”). The company recently introduced the brand name Allied Cycle Works, and its Alfa bicycle models.
The company began in early 2016, according to James Huang, global tech editor for bicycling blog and web site Cycling Tips (https://cyclingtips.com/2018/06/allied-alfa-allroad-long-term-review-the-antidote-to-the-n1-rule/ ), when the founders bought the assets of a bankrupt Canadian bike manufacturer and brought everything to Little Rock. A team came together that included, in HIA Velo’s words, “…current and former bicycle racers, speed junkies, and enthusiasts. We love bicycles and are endlessly in the pursuit of…classic, strong, utilitarian design.” Founder Tony Karklins (who has since left the company) says in a recent LinkedIn article that the great advantage of producing bikes in-house is that you can communicate and implement design changes instantly: “Conventional wisdom in the bike industry says that carbon fiber bike manufacturing can only be accomplished in Asia. We think that’s ridiculous. Because our engineering team works on the factory floor, [we can] implement process improvements as needed and make constant improvement.” He adds that one of the challenges of dealing with Asian factories is the need to forecast up to two years ahead of when you need the product, and, if that product has a problem, you then have a warehouse full of that problem: “With domestic just-in-time manufacturing, we never have compromised product on hand and you always get our latest and best work.”
HIA Velo’s director of engineering Sam Pickman, who came to the company from Specialized Bicycle Components (Morgan Hill, CA, US), tells me that “designing and making carbon fiber bikes involves compromises that you try to overcome. You must balance stiffness and handling with ridability and comfort.” Allied Cycle Works’ Alfa frames are typically made with 6 plies of Mitsubishi Chemical Carbon Fiber & Composites Inc.’s (Irvine, CA, US) unidirectional carbon prepreg, including 130 gsm standard modulus carbon and 110 gsm intermediate modulus carbon, prepregged with Mitsubishi’s Newport 301 epoxy resin and supplied in 1m-wide rolls. Pickman also reports that the company is investigating 114 gsm TeXtreme spread-tow woven material supplied by Oxeon (Boras, Sweden), as an alternative to unidirectional prepreg. Pickman acknowledges that the lightweight carbon fiber frame tubes can be damaged, because carbon fiber is brittle, and riders crash, particularly those involved in racing: “And typically they can’t see the damage, after the crash, so riders get back on, keep going, and then the unseen damage propagates and the frame can unexpectedly come apart.”
Pickman adds that the tooling for the bicycle parts, supplied by Southwest Pattern Works (Albuquerque, NM, US) is the tooling provider for all carbon fiber molds: “As we were starting up we struggled to find a tooling shop that was a match for us until we were introduced to John Groth and his team. They don't just simply open your files and make to the print, they look at the parts critically and offer suggestions.” Pickman goes on to say that on two occasions the toolmaker found mistakes in tooling models that saved pain down the road. “Our relationship with HIA has helped expedite their quick product launch and part quality,” says Groth.
Here’s how HIA Velo is making their composite better: adding plies of Innegra Technologies’ (Greenville, SC, US) woven biaxial Innegra S high-modulus polypropylene fabrics to areas of the Alfa bike frames. “We use the Innegra fiber for two purposes. The first is to provide flex — the polypropylene is very flexible, ductile and damps vibrations, so that it increases ride comfort. The second purpose is that it is flexible, tough and absorbs impact, so we use it in the areas of the frame that are potentially most damage-prone.” The graphic below, taken from one of HIA Velo’s videos, shows those areas of the frame where the Innegra prepreg material is incorporated: the seat stays, the top tube where the handlebars could impact the tube, and the fork crown, which, says Pickman, “is a part you never want to break.” Innegra’s composites specialist and long-time industry expert Russ Emanis assisted HIA Velo with incorporation of the Innegra material, which is sized for compatibility with epoxy resin, into the Little Rock production line, including appropriate oven ramps and temperature dwells.
The company typically incorporates the Innegra plies in the center of the tube layup, encapsulated within carbon plies, with the Innegra often forming the innermost ply of the tube. This, says Pickman, gives the best result based on their testing. When I ask why not use more of the Innegra throughout the frame, he explains “The polypropylene adds weight, and no stiffness. We have to pick and choose where we want the flex and ductility, because weight is a factor.” Models incorporating the Innegra reinforcements include the Alfa road racer with rim brakes, and the Alfa All-Road model. Watch this video about how and where Innegra is used to increase damage tolerance in the Alfa frames:
For more information about HIA Velo/Allied Cycle Works, this factory tour video narrated by Pickman gives an overview of the company operation:
James Huang’s Cycling Tips blogs can be accessed from the HIA Velo/Allied Cycle Works web site: https://alliedcycleworks.com/.
Commercial production of recycled carbon fiber currently outpaces applications for it, but materials characterization and new technology demonstrations promise to close the gap.
Yes, advanced forms are in development, but has the technology progressed enough to make the business case?
Compared to legacy materials like steel, aluminum, iron and titanium, composites are still coming of age, and only just now are being better understood by design and manufacturing engineers. However, composites’ physical properties — combined with unbeatable light weight — make them undeniably attractive.