Syensqo high performance materials
Published

All-Composite Platforms?

    Gibson describes how a team representing the Centre for Composite Materials Engineering, MSP (formerly Maunsell Structural Plastics, Beckenham, Kent, U.K.) and Odebrecht Oil and Gas, a Brazilian-owned platform fabrication company, were tasked with redesigning the topside of BP’s small, minimum-facility Davy-Be

Share

    Gibson describes how a team representing the Centre for Composite Materials Engineering, MSP (formerly Maunsell Structural Plastics, Beckenham, Kent, U.K.) and Odebrecht Oil and Gas, a Brazilian-owned platform fabrication company, were tasked with redesigning the topside of BP’s small, minimum-facility Davy-Bessemer monopod platforms. Under the umbrella of the United Kingdom’s Advanced Research Partnership (ARP) collaborative research program, the group investigated the potential for weight savings with a composite design of the monopod platform, which comprised a single vertical column, supporting a three-deck topside for oil production. The redesign effort was overseen by a group of project sponsors, including Mobil and Amoco, and followed regulatory guidelines applicable to metallic structures, issued by the United Kingdom’s Health and Safety Executive (HSE). The Davy-Bessemer was chosen because of its relatively small size, which minimized the scale of large composite structure fabrication. The fact that the monopod is “not normally manned,” or visited only infrequently for maintenance simplified some design decisions related to staff accommodations and fire safety.

    Initially, a “conforming” redesign was conducted, which retained the same floor dimensions and overall equipment layout as the original. Key to the design was a structure of multi-cellular interlocking beams for the decks. Each consisted of 38 pultruded square tubes, overwrapped with fabric wetout with vinyl ester resin to form a deep rectangular box beam. The beams would be interlocked laterally by means of pultruded tubes, to allow loadsharing across the elements of the structure. This allowed gaps, where necessary, between each beam to accommodate the requirement for an “open” deck in case of spillage. A similar cellular beam structure was envisioned for the vertical supports between decks. At the time the design was carried out, says Gibson, it was not possible to obtain pultruded beam sections of sufficient depth. Just a year after the initial design, however, Strongwell’s (Bristol, Va., U.S.A.) double-web beam became available.

    “A sandwich panel design was rejected because, with currently available foam thicknesses, it was not possible to make a sandwich deck of sufficient depth to achieve the stiffness and strength that was required for the deck loading,” says Gibson. The “conforming” design, essentially a substitution of composite beams for steel beams, achieved a savings of 38 percent in weight and 7 percent in cost, compared to that of the original steel solution.

    In an effort to show how composites could be utilized to even greater benefit, a second, “radical” design was undertaken, which allowed rearrangement and reconfiguration of decks and equipment, as long as the design maintained necessary functionality. Using a similar beam concept, the radical solution was found to be 55 percent lighter than steel and 26 percent less costly. Gibson points out that starting with a clean sheet of paper rather than copying a metallic structure allows the designer to use the characteristics of composites to best advantage. Gibson has explored a similar concept for helidecks in a study undertaken with Odebrecht and Vosper Thornycroft (Southampton, U.K.) also under the ARP umbrella. Weight reductions up to 50 percent were found to be possible, using composite cellular box beams for an all-composite upper deck and underlying support structure.

    The composite monopods and helidecks have not been built. “We’re hoping for a product champion,” Gibson explains. “The monopod platform concept is intended for relatively shallow, marginal production, likely in the North Sea, if it’s built.” An advantage of the composite topside is that it is reuseable — once the production is depleted, the platform can be lifted and readily moved to another location. Gibson predicts, “Twenty years from now, these larger structures will be routine.”

Kent Pultrusion
custom hydraulic press
U.S. Polychemical Acrastrip
TOPCON24
Wabash
Toray Advanced Composites
Master Bond
NewStar Adhesives - Nautical Adhesives
Carbon Fiber 2024
CW Tech Days Sustainability - Register Today!
Keyland Polymer
CAMX 2024

Related Content

Pultrusion

Toyota Tundra composite seatback design awarded 2022 Altair Enlighten Award

BASF, Flex-N-Gate, L&L Products and Toyota limited an all-steel assembly, cutting 60 parts down to four composite pieces for 20% weight savings.  

Read More
Pultrusion

Saertex expands production range with pultruded planks for rotor blades

SAERplanks pultruded profiles, opening new avenues in the wind industry, comprise heavy-tow carbon fibers produced using a novel hybrid resin system for reliable performance, high productivity and minimum scrap rates.

Read More
Automation

Twenco develops sensors for smart molds and process control in resin infusion and composites welding

Non-invasive DEA and NDT Analyzer for multi-parameter monitoring, QA and control, including real time simulation feed and 3D process visualization across and through composite parts.

Read More
Autoclave

Materials & Processes: Fabrication methods

There are numerous methods for fabricating composite components. Selection of a method for a particular part, therefore, will depend on the materials, the part design and end-use or application. Here's a guide to selection.

Read More

Read Next

ATL/AFP

A Different, All-Composite Approach

    Fiberglass Structural Engineering Inc. (FSE, Bellingham, Wash., U.S.A.) has patented its innovative concept for a hybrid fiberglass and steel platform. Approximately 50 percent of the volume of a conventional steel spar hull would be replaced by hollow filament-wound Eglass and vinyl ester tubes, from 10 ft to

Read More
Out of Autoclave

Changing The Paradigm

    In Gibson’s opinion, large composite structures will be proven onshore, in civil infrastructure. “What will happen is that large pultruded parts and those made with other means will become commonplace,” he maintains, “and then the technology will migrate to other areas, including offshore oil.”     Dr. Char

Read More
ATL/AFP

Composite Trusses For Large Structures?

    Ebert Composites Corp. (Chula Vista, Calif., U.S.A.) is marketing a composite truss concept for large structures that has potential for offshore application. Since 1992, the company has focused on the development of large, all-composite lattice-type power transmission towers to replace galvanized steel towers.

Read More
Chem Trend