Wind energy: No blades needed?
A startup seeks to take the blades out of wind generators.
Vortex Bladeless (Boston, MA, US) believes that wind energy could use an extreme makeover. Instead of capturing energy via the rotational motion of a turbine, the company has developed a wind generator, called the Vortex, which is a carbon-fiber intensive wind generator without blades. The Vortex takes advantage of what’s known as vorticity, an aerodynamic effect that occurs when wind breaks against a solid structure. The Vortex structure starts to oscillate, and captures the energy that is produced.
The company claims it hasn’t simply just removed the blades, but rather designed it to have no parts in contact at all. (So no gears, linkages, etc.).
Vortex integrates the tower and generator into one structure, requiring less moving parts and less material to produce the same amount of electricity. It also eliminates the nacelle, the support mechanisms and the blades. As cost is a big driver for just about everything, Vortex Bladeless touts that manufacturing savings are roughly estimated at around 53% of the usual wind turbine production cost. And the company claims that the Vortex will produce energy at a 40% lower cost than a comparable wind installation.
Vortex has five main parts: the foundation, rod, generation system, tuning system and mast. The carbon fiber rod gives strength and flexibility to the movement, while minimizing energy dissipation. And the mast is a light circular structure made of fiberglass and carbon fiber. The mast acts a wind breaker that generates the oscillatory movement thanks to what the company calls the ‘Vortex Shedding’ effect.
Company officials do caution that the Vortex is not immune to fatigue. The wind can cause twisting and displacement of the structure, primarily in the elastic rod and especially in the lower section that has to withstand greater forces. However, studies carried out by Vortex Bladeless reportedly confirm that the stress on the rod is far from the working limit of the materials. Computational modeling estimates operational lifetime of the installation to be between 32 and 96 years.
Vortex Bladeless has finalized wind tunnel tests, most of the R&D is done and they have a working prototype. The company also has multiple patents of its technology. Execs also have launched a crowdfunding campaign that will help it create the commercial pilot for its first product, Vortex Atlantis (100 W).
While the technology is quite inventive, bringing such a radical new product to the wind energy field is not an easy feat.
For instance, a recent article in the MIT Technology Review took a critical eye to the technology.
“If you have a common propeller-type wind turbine, you have a big area swept by the blades,” says Martin Hansen, a wind energy specialist at the Technical University of Denmark. “Here you just have a pole.”
In addition to capturing less energy, oscillating cylinders can’t convert as much of that energy into electricity, Hansen says. A conventional wind turbine typically converts 80 to 90% of the kinetic energy of its spinning rotor into electricity. David Yáñez says his company’s custom-built linear generator will have a conversion efficiency of 70%.
Is this bladeless wind generator too good to be true? Or will it become the new normal?
Related Content
One-piece, one-shot, 17-meter wing spar for high-rate aircraft manufacture
GKN Aerospace has spent the last five years developing materials strategies and resin transfer molding (RTM) for an aircraft trailing edge wing spar for the Airbus Wing of Tomorrow program.
Read MoreCycling forward with bike frame materials and processes
Fine-tuning of conventional materials and processes characterizes today’s CFRP bicycle frame manufacturing, whether in the large factories of Asia or at reshored facilities in North America and Europe. Thermoplastic resins and automated processes are on the horizon, though likely years away from high-volume production levels.
Read MoreInfinite Composites: Type V tanks for space, hydrogen, automotive and more
After a decade of proving its linerless, weight-saving composite tanks with NASA and more than 30 aerospace companies, this CryoSphere pioneer is scaling for growth in commercial space and sustainable transportation on Earth.
Read MoreMaterials & Processes: Composites fibers and resins
Compared to legacy materials like steel, aluminum, iron and titanium, composites are still coming of age, and only just now are being better understood by design and manufacturing engineers. However, composites’ physical properties — combined with unbeatable light weight — make them undeniably attractive.
Read MoreRead Next
Composites end markets: Energy (2024)
Composites are used widely in oil/gas, wind and other renewable energy applications. Despite market challenges, growth potential and innovation for composites continue.
Read MoreCW’s 2024 Top Shops survey offers new approach to benchmarking
Respondents that complete the survey by April 30, 2024, have the chance to be recognized as an honoree.
Read MoreFrom the CW Archives: The tale of the thermoplastic cryotank
In 2006, guest columnist Bob Hartunian related the story of his efforts two decades prior, while at McDonnell Douglas, to develop a thermoplastic composite crytank for hydrogen storage. He learned a lot of lessons.
Read More